Blog

Drafting a Florida Will That Can Survive a Will Contest 

By Rice Law
Drafting a Florida Will That Can Survive a Will Contest

If you ask most individuals to describe the function of a will, chances are the majority will be able to at least state that it is a document used to transfer property upon one’s passing. When a will is challenged, the dispute may turn on how it was signed, what the maker understood, or whether someone pushed the maker. 

This battle is not always easy and is often decided based on the ability to introduce strong, contradictory evidence. A good way to reduce the risk of will litigation is to develop a clear estate plan with an attorney, and to ensure it is updated regularly. It cannot stop every challenge. 

Florida’s Signing Rules Come First 

One question many clients have is how formal a document has to be in order for it to be considered a valid will. 

To begin, in order for a document to constitute a valid will in the state of Florida it must be in writing. A will can never be oral. Section 732.502 says “The testator must sign the will at the end.” 

Although someone can sign on his or her behalf as a proxy, he or she must do so in the presence of the testator and at the testator’s direction. Whenever the testator or the proxy signs the will, they must do so in the presence of at least two witnesses. A testator who signed earlier can instead acknowledge that signature in front of both witnesses. The witnesses must then also sign the document in the presence of the testator and in the presence of each other. 

While this might seem like a burdensome formality, it is important not to take shortcuts as Florida courts strictly enforce all execution requirements. 

While the testator can choose to have one of their beneficiaries sign the will, that is not necessarily a good idea as it can lead to claims of undue influence and self-interest can affect credibility. Under Section 732.504(2), the will “is not invalid because the will or codicil is signed by an interested witness.” 

The Self-Proving Affidavit 

It is generally a good idea to include in the will what is known as a “self proof affidavit.” A self proof affidavit is sworn testimony that the execution of the will followed Florida law. Both the testator and the witnesses will sign the affidavit before a notary, which will in turn avoid the need for witnesses to later attest to proper execution. 

Under Section 733.201(1), “Self-proved wills executed in accordance with this code may be admitted to probate without further proof.” In a contest, the affidavit helps show the will was properly signed, but it does not end questions about capacity or undue influence. 

Being of Sound Mind 

Florida law requires that a person be of “sound mind” in order to make a Will. This is also known as having “testamentary capacity.” Section 732.501 adds an age rule: the person must be “either 18 or more years of age or an emancipated minor.” 

The test for testamentary capacity is whether the person making the Will has the ability, at the time the Will is being made, to understand three things. The first is the nature and extent of the property to be disposed of. The second is the maker’s relation to those who would naturally claim a substantial benefit from his Will. The third is a general understanding of the practical effect of the Will as executed. 

Although testamentary capacity is presumed, a common ground for contesting an estate plan is a claim that the individual lacked testamentary capacity. 

The law does not prescribe an age limit beyond which a person may not dispose of property, but diminished capacity is more common in clients who are of advanced age. The longer one waits to make a Will the greater the chance an unhappy relative may claim that he or she was of unsound mind. 

In order to address such potential claims, the attorney can conduct a thorough interview with their client asking pointed questions designed to assess capacity. When circumstances warrant it, they can also recommend that the client meet with their doctor near the day the Will is executed to help document testamentary capacity. 

If memory loss or a diagnosis such as Alzheimer’s or dementia raises a concern, the attorney should check whether the person meets this test at the time of signing. No attorney wants to turn away a client in need, but one cannot ethically allow someone to sign a key document when they lack the capacity that document requires. 

Undue Influence and Who Has to Prove It 

Family members can become vulnerable. This can be hard to accept, but oftentimes those we love fall ill or otherwise reach an advanced age where their mental capacities are diminished. They do not recognize that they may be a target for someone who is pretending to love them or care for them with the ulterior motive of gaining a quick inheritance. 

Section 732.5165 states that “A will is void if the execution is procured by fraud, duress, mistake, or undue influence.” If only part of the will was procured that way, only that part fails. The “remainder of the will not so procured shall be valid if it is not invalid for other reasons.” 

Under In re Estate of Carpenter, 253 So. 2d 697 (Fla. 1971), a presumption of undue influence can arise when a substantial beneficiary had a confidential relationship with the testator and was active in procuring the will. Section 733.107(2) calls it “a presumption shifting the burden of proof.” Once evidence sufficient to establish the presumption has been presented, the person defending the will must come forward and overcome it. 

Communication with family is also important, as will litigation is often based on a lack of understanding between family members as to what was desired. If a child or caregiver who benefits under the will helped arrange the appointment, tell your attorney. 

Electronic Wills and Remote Witnesses 

Technically speaking, any piece of paper can serve as a will so long as it satisfies certain requirements as to formality. Since 2020, Florida has also allowed electronic wills. Section 732.522 says “Any requirement that an instrument be signed may be satisfied by an electronic signature.” 

Witnesses can appear by video, but only in an online notary session that follows Section 117.285. The notary must ask the person signing a set of questions, including “Who is in the room with you?” Remote witnessing “is not effective for witnessing the signature of a principal who is a vulnerable adult.” 

One of the easiest ways to encounter an estate planning problem is to use pre-made, boilerplate forms that do not account for the complexities of individual planning. 

When and How a Will Can Be Challenged 

Probate is nothing more than the court-supervised process of gathering someone’s assets; paying taxes, claims, and expenses; and then distributing those assets in accordance with the decedent’s Will. In other words, probate is the vehicle by which a Will is validated and then utilized. 

Section 732.518 says a contest “may not be commenced before the death of the testator.” 

Under Section 733.212(3), an interested person on whom a copy of the notice of administration is served must object to the validity of the will within 3 months after service, “or those objections are forever barred.” If you think that a family member did not have testamentary capacity for a Will that is being admitted to probate, it is important to speak with an attorney early about the deadline that applies to you. 

If you are making your own will, you may wonder about a clause that cuts out anyone who contests it. Under Section 732.517, “A provision in a will purporting to penalize any interested person for contesting the will or instituting other proceedings relating to the estate is unenforceable.” 

Check your own will and estate planning documents. If you or a family member has married, divorced, had a child or other life changing situations, your estate planning documents may need to be updated. We have seen many situations in which someone has created their estate planning documents and not checked them for years. 

How Rice Law Firm Can Help 

Making a will does not have to be difficult or arduous. If you are considering creating or updating a will, you can reach Matthew Shapiro at our Daytona Beach office at 386-257-1222 to review the document, the signing arrangements and any circumstances that may invite a dispute. He is a partner whose practice includes wills, trusts, advance directives and estate planning, as well as probate and estate litigation. Rice Law Firm’s Volusia County lawyers have been helping local families since 1983. 

This article is for general information only and should not be construed as legal advice. 

Rice Law Firm